Taxpayers Paying More for Lawmakers’ Benefits

Health benefits and annual cost-of-living adjustment could total $6,000 per-member increase

By Jared Sichel | PA Independent

HARRISBURG — Pennsylvania taxpayers, who are struggling with tough economic decisions, will be paying House and Senate lawmakers more for their prescription and dental benefits this year.

And those same lawmakers also are expecting a salary increase in December just in time for the holidays.

The recently approved $27.656 billion budget includes $1.7 million, mostly for prescription and dental benefits with $1.4 million going to the House’s 203 members and $300,000 to the state Senate’s 50 members.

If lawmakers receive the cost-of-living increase, House and Senate members’ annual compensation, including salary and benefits, could increase by at least $6,000 per member, according to Senate Chief Clerk’s Office.

Last year, total compensation for all lawmakers’ salaries and medical benefits was about $32.3 million.

Eric Epstein, founder of Rock the Capital, a Harrisburg-based political watchdog group, said legislators are out of touch with voters.

The average Pennsylvania family does not get subsidized ‘Cadillac’ health care,” Epstein said. “Until these guys that govern us understand how hard it is to get by day to day, to pay health care, they’re not going to be able to pass legislation that improves the quality of life for Pennsylvanians.”

Lawmakers pay 1 percent of their salaries toward health benefits as opposed to their constituents who contribute 2 percent, according to data collected by the National Conference of State Legislators, a bipartisan organization that serves the legislators and staffs of the nation’s 50 states, and the federal Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Base pay for legislators this year is more than $80,000, and lawmakers in leadership positions make more than $100,000.

Meanwhile, the median income for a Pennsylvania household is about $50,000, according to the U.S. Census Bureau.

Erik Arneson, spokesman for Senate Majority Leader Dominic Pileggi, R-Chester, said Senate Republicans do “understand fully the difficult economic situation that Pennsylvania is in.”

“Much of our work this session has been targeted to improving the economic condition of our state,” Arneson said. “Increased health-care costs are an issue for every employer, whether in the private sector or the public sector.”

While some costs of the state’s full-time Legislature are going up, the money allocated to fund the state House and Senate was cut by about $800,000 in the recently approved budget. Last year, nearly $273 million helped pay for the Legislature’s operations.

The reduction is due to ongoing streamlining of other costs, primarily printing costs.

I think (printing and legislative expense accounts) have decreased considerably over the last three or four years,” said state Rep. Bill Adolph, R-Delaware.

Even though salaries comprise the bulk of lawmaker compensation, benefits — ranging from health and dental plans to per diems of $163 — increase how much House and Senate members make. 

Preferred provider organization health insurance plans for each of the 203 House members and their families cost taxpayers between $4,543 and $20,420 in fiscal 2011-12, according to the Bucks County Courier Times.

Most full-time House employees are enrolled in plans worth at least $6,855. Plans for each of the 50 state senators and their families range from $6,969 to $19,311.

While most lawmakers have health insurance plans worth at least $6,800, the average private-sector employee in Pennsylvania is enrolled in a plan worth about $5,000, according to 2010 data collected by NCSL.

Lawmakers have not once voted to increase their salaries since they repealed their own controversial pay raise in 2005, in which state lawmakers voted to increase their salaries from less than $70,000 to more than $81,000.

But benefit increases and COLAs have allowed House and Senate members to increase their compensation without facing a repeat of the voter anger politicians faced seven years ago.

Solely due to COLA increases, state lawmakers now make about $82,000 per year in salary.

COLAs adjust legislative salaries based on the Philadelphia region’s consumer price index. Any compensation increase in the upcoming budget would come on top of a 3 percent, or $2,500 salary increase that General Assembly members received in December 2011 as part of their annual COLAs.

State Sen. Mike Folmer, R-Lebanon, returns his COLA increases to the state Treasury and does not participate in the state’s pension system or the Legislature’s medical, prescription drug, or dental programs.

Folmer’s Chief of Staff Fred Sembach in an e-mail said that Folmer’s position is based on Article II, Section 8 of the Pennsylvania Constitution: “Health care for legislators is not provided for.”Medical and dental insurance contracts for this fiscal year will be available on the Treasury’s website in August.


Patrice Sidoione All That Salon July 09, 2012 at 05:18 PM
SWT would you explain this convention more? Plus I would like to understand is it now law to provide for the rats or not? Based on what you mentioned the PA Constitution does not provide for what they are getting??? So Could it be unadded??? Pat Brown's law was stacked to have one & one place qualify...how is that lawful??? I have personally never been in such close proxsimity to unadulterated greed I found it shocking & unsettling! The comment that too the cake was that his second wife, his former secratery, is the lobbyist for the arena & that was not connected to his writing the legislation! A coinsodence from what I read...I found that remark insulting & dismissive! How do we make his removal a target??? How does this type of thing get exposed when so many people with money power cover up & negate what is actually happening? I for one am willing to work WORK at exposing this type of disregard & self seving harlotry...certainly it must be stopped or we are going to colapse as a middle class or even working poor...I have no desire to be a Molly McGuire slave to corporate control! Finally, I think the institution is more like a tv set... neutral, inatimate! THE PROGRAMING is the problem & the programing is done by human beings! And these human beings are not even to the calibur of prostitutes as that would be a fair exchange...They are simply self serving takers aka harlots!
Patrice Sidoione All That Salon July 09, 2012 at 05:18 PM
Sadly this is true!
Patrice Sidoione All That Salon July 09, 2012 at 05:26 PM
I think they are operating from their reality! The problem is not that they do not know...IT IS THEY DO NOT UNDERSTAND OR CARE...a combination of both! We have become a nation of people that has again vilified the poor, almost criminal to be poor or working class like we are substandard and negligible! Definitely not considered necessary! So what do we do to make them loose their jobs??? Not that I think they should be jobs but rather public service...Maybe if they had to really work for a living in the communities they decimate they would have a different tact!
David Brugger July 10, 2012 at 03:47 PM
I have been proposing this for years. My solution is to use registered voters rolls, randomly choose from each US district,one person who will serve for 5 years at good pay and benefits. There can be no lobbying or acceptance of any gifts to any so chosen representative. Each person will serve for this one term and can never again be a representative. They can only pass laws that affect everyone int he country, that is, no especial legislation or appropriations for any specific district or group. It will be considered your patriotic duty as a citizen to serve with consideration for those who are simply unable to serve. The U.S. certainly could not do any worse than what we have now.
Chris Miller July 10, 2012 at 05:21 PM
SWT You are right on the money. WE have allowed officials to set themselves up in short order to the poin that it is difficult to defeat them at the state and federal level. But we must do it. Here again the "Term limits" amendment must be put in place other wise we will be looking at a tyrannical government that we put in office Chris Miller


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »