Tell Us: Should Larry Stoudt Resign from Nazareth Borough Council?

A Nazareth resident questions the future of a troubled councilman; the answer doesn't arrive in a pretty package with a simple bow.

Five absentee ballots in November 2011 allowed Larry Stoudt to retain his seat on Nazareth Borough Council until 2016. He has served on Council for more than 30 years. 

“I'm going to do the best I can and work for the betterment of the community,” Stoudt told Patch after his competitor, Thomas Heckman, conceded defeat. 

One year and three days later, a Palmer Township district judge ordered Stoudt, who is facing charges of obstructing a state police probe, to stay out of borough Police Department headquarters.

During Council’s Nov. 19 Police Committee meeting, a resident asked about Stoudt’s future as an elected official.

“He’s charged. He hasn’t been adjudicated yet,” explained Dan Chiavaroli, president of Council. “Only the governor can remove him, or he has to resign on his own.”

Should Larry Stoudt Resign from Nazareth Borough Council? Tell us in the comments section below.

According to Act 43 of 2012, which modernized and recodified the Borough Code, “Only the courts have the authority to remove an elected official for conviction of serious crimes under Pennsylvania constitution.” 

The state Department of Community & Economic Development adds, “[The] Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled in 1995 that the Pennsylvania State Constitution only allows an elected official to be removed from office through impeachment, conviction of a crime, or misbehavior in office.”

Although citizens cannot force a council member to resign, Chiavaroli said they could submit letters asking Stoudt to consider that route.

Stoudt, 74, was charged Oct. 9 with one misdemeanor count of criminal attempt-obstruction of law or government for allegedly trying to interfere with a Pennsylvania State Police undercover investigation. He faces a maximum of two years in prison and $5,000 in fines. 

He waived his right to a preliminary hearing Nov. 21 in front of District Judge Jackie Taschner. He said he plans to apply for the Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition (ARD) program for first-time offenders.

Stoudt allegedly asked Nazareth's police chief to run the driver's license of a suspected liquor enforcement officer, court records say, in an attempt to protect the local American Legion post from undercover, prying eyes. 

According to a police criminal complaint, Stoudt approached police Chief Thomas Trachta with his request at borough Police Department headquarters on May 24, exactly one month after the Pennsylvania State Police Liquor Enforcement Office executed a search warrant on the Nazareth Jacksonian Club.

Stoudt told Taschner that as chairman of council's Public Property Committee, he is permitted to enter the police department. But, he noted, other committee members can handle his duties when the police department is involved.

As part of his bail conditions, Taschner ordered Stoudt to not enter borough Police Department headquarters. 

During last week’s Police Committee meeting, Chiavaroli noted -- when prompted -- that Stoudt’s legal fees are not being paid for by taxpayer money.

Stoudt isn’t the only Lehigh Valley councilman in the headlines for something unflattering.

  • Teen Alburtis Councilman Kyle Avery Bower was jailed Oct. 15 after allegedly tearing up a soybean field by driving through it - and violating probation in the process. He's also charged with stealing political signs. A few days after his arrest, according to a story in The Morning Call, Bower resigned his seat on Alburtis Council.
  • Macungie Councilman Linn Walker apologized in Lehigh County Court as he pleaded guilty to repeatedly urinating outdoors and in front of young children. That incident occurred in early August. Walker said he would resign from Macungie Council, but recanted after he said he was told by other council members he did not have to resign.

Nazareth Borough Council will hold a workshop at 7 p.m. Thursday, Nov. 29. The monthly business meeting will be held on Monday, Dec. 3.

Arthur November 27, 2012 at 02:46 PM
If guilty he should resign.
Louise (Roth) Gosma November 27, 2012 at 03:36 PM
Yes. I'm no longer a resident of Nazareth but have known this guy from the time he was a spoiled little mommy's boy. He has done things that in my mind are not acceptable for a politician or member of the Borough Council.
Susan Derr Kirk November 27, 2012 at 03:48 PM
thirty years is too long for anyone
alivettg November 27, 2012 at 08:06 PM
Yes, resign!! Found guilty or NOT!!
Ben Miller November 27, 2012 at 08:50 PM
There is no question of whether he is guilty or not, he has already admitted to doing it. From Patch article- http://nazareth.patch.com/articles/judge-prohibits-nazareth-councilman-from-entering-police-station "Troopers Rick Malone and Michael Romano met with Stoudt on July 3 at his home on E. Center Street. Stoudt explained he found the photocopied driver's license at the Harold V. Knecht Post 415 American Legion, where a customer said the woman was the liquor enforcement officer involved in the Nazareth Jacksonian Club raid. He asked Trachta to run the license “as a friend,” according to court records. Stoudt added that he knew the chief informed Mayor Fred Daugherty Jr. about his request, "and that he should have known better as he is 'on council.'" Stoudt said he shredded the photocopy after the chief's refusal. "His reasoning for looking into the driver's license, court records say, is because the American Legion and the Jacksonian Club are "sister clubs." If "Jessica Harhai" was a liquor enforcement officer who "busted the Jacksonian, then he did not want the same thing to happen at the Legion." ----------------------------------------------- I believe he should resign, in the best interest of Nazareth and its residents. The borough already faces a crisis with the police department not being able to adequately protect the citizens of Nazareth, due to a lack of funding and an overabundance of interference by the Council and Mayor.
Ben Miller November 27, 2012 at 09:04 PM
By the way, I am also an active member of the Nazareth American Legion and Councilman Stout needs to understand he has done the club a huge disservice. His actions don't just reflect badly upon himself, they reflect on the Council, Nazareth Borough and the American Legion. He took it upon himself to inject the American Legion into a situation that makes it appear as if we are doing something illegal or inappropriate. The Harold V. Knecht post of the American Legion in Nazareth is a fine organization who's active membership is made up entirely of veterans who served America during a time of war. We do many great things for the community and for other veterans, while instilling a sense of citizenship and American pride in local children. Mr. Stout, himself, is a veteran and for that, I salute him. I appreciate the sacrifices he made in the service and nothing he does now can take away from all that he did back then. Nazareth, however, is suffering, because of his admittedly inappropriate actions and he needs to do the right thing.
alivettg November 27, 2012 at 10:06 PM
Well said!!
JASON GABRIEL November 27, 2012 at 10:44 PM
To request the resignation of an individual, allows the person to say no. The proper procedure in this matter is impeachment or govenors order of removal, due to misconduct. To ask a person to do the right thing, when he used his position to do many wrong things, is ridiculous. Take the initiative and take back part of your town. Send the message, by action, that you the citizens will correct the problems that are being allowed to exist. Thank you.
rick troxell November 27, 2012 at 11:12 PM
You would think he would step down and apologize. Not likely even though he basicly admitted his guilt. Rev Mats didn't have the integrity to apologize for his mistake in judgement either. It trully is not in keeping with anything Colonial.
alivettg November 27, 2012 at 11:51 PM
How many names do you think we could get on a petition by the 3rd , to be read in front of council requesting him resign? By stating he will be requesting ARD, is a guilty plea if you ask me. Regardless, no matter what the courts decide, it was still an act of misuse of authority, and adds to the disturbed reputation this town is quickly acquiring. Stepping down would be the moral thing to do, and the LEAST the citizens deserve at this point! He has no place in making decisions any longer.
sherry November 28, 2012 at 12:52 AM
Yes, Mr. Stoudt should resign.
JASON GABRIEL November 28, 2012 at 01:10 AM
Yes, he should resign. However, the choice is left to him. Even if he does resign, the remaining council has the ability to refuse or reject the resignation. Everyone in the whole town could sign a petition, and you could be ignored, which leaves you with a term lasting until 2016. Make your choices toward orders being given folks.
rick troxell November 28, 2012 at 07:38 PM
Everyone is going to have an opinion on this. Please don't make this the only focus you have. Mr.Stoudt will get what he deserves be it now or in his future. Keep your energy directed towards what direction this Borough is headed. Hopefully not this sort of arrogance any longer. Show your support for Nazareth and attend the workshop and council meeting. Hear first hand what direction our Borough gov't feels is best and voice opinion both in mtg and in public. They may be the elected officials but are they the true voice of the taxpayers? The people of this Borough have obviously been complacent for a long time and allowed the Gov't to do the same. All council commisions and council mtgs are posted on the Nazareth Borough website under calendar. As are your council representatives phone numbers and terms. Get involved. You may not always like what you hear but at least ou can say you are involved and care.
Grossy November 28, 2012 at 11:54 PM
30 years as a councilman and you want his resignation but not his position. You must have voted for Tom Heckman. Let him alone, who did he harm? The Legion, Nazareth, the police... I think not. I'm glad he took a stance to check this person out. With a last name like Harhai ( not a common name in the Barony of the Rose) Larry took the bull by the horns and asked the chief to check it out. He refused. No harm, no foul. If anything, he has already been slapped on the wrist and told not to do it again. Get over it.
Kaos8 November 29, 2012 at 03:40 AM
Who does this guy have dirt on that he still has a job? Many people in political jobs (not necessarily elected) in this county, yes, including Nazareth, have lost their jobs for less than this. This guy admitted to doing this, but apparently, does not see that it was wrong? How bad is it in Nazareth, that some of you think it is OK for him to be in a leadership position in your town? In the last couple of years I have seen a lot of things in Nazareth head in a downward spiral. It seems that everyone wants to complain, but apparently, still vote for this guy?
Kaos8 November 29, 2012 at 03:48 AM
If a Judge tells him to stay out of the police headquarters, chances are he should not be on the town council. This was not a personal matter, where he just did not get along with someone, this was a legal situation, where he stuck his nose where it did not belong. It was not even originally a local police matter, it is a Liquor Control Board and State Police matter, which is even bigger yet. How is it people are not getting the bigger picture, it is more than just a local problem now. Wrong is wrong, no matter how you look at it- it should not matter who it is. I do not live in Nazareth limits, but if I did, you can bet, I would be at meetings and rallying all of my neighbors to do the same.
Jeepers63 November 29, 2012 at 08:38 PM


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something