What Makes a Teacher Good?

Pennsylvania is seeking to revamp its teacher evaluation system. Should an educator’s job be tied to student test scores?

I sometimes think that good teaching is a bit like Potter Stewart’s description of hard-core pornography. The late Supreme Court justice said he wasn’t sure he could define it but he knew it when he saw it. 

Most of us could probably describe a great teacher we had with adjectives that are hard to quantify: creative, motivating, innovative, passionate, tough but fair, funny, dedicated and interesting. But how do you gauge those qualities in an evaluation system for teachers? 

Pennsylvania is moving toward replacing its antiquated system that deems teachers either satisfactory or unsatisfactory. Under the state’s proposal, teachers would be rated distinguished, proficient, needs improvement or failing. State House Bill 1980, introduced by state Rep. Ryan Aument, R-41st, would put revised evaluations in place by the 2013-2014 school year.  

Parkland School District is taking part in the pilot project for the new evaluations and School Board member Roberta Marcus said the assessment looks at different aspects of teaching to allow for more nuanced conclusions aimed at making all teachers better. “Our goal is how do we improve teacher effectiveness in the classroom?” she said. 

That’s all to the good. But while half of a teacher’s rating would rely on classroom observations of such skills as preparedness, classroom management and interaction, the other half depends on students’ test scores. 

The trouble with that is it’s difficult to isolate the cause of a student’s success or failure on a subject, according to Parkland School Board member Bob Bold. Suppose a third grade teacher gets a good evaluation because her students did well on the Pennsylvania System of School Assessment (PSSA.) What if much of their success was largely due to the excellent second grade teacher who had taught them the year before? “What happened in previous grades affects how kids test,” Bold said. 

The new evaluations would also incorporate what’s called value-added models into teacher evaluations. Such models essentially look at a student’s past test scores to predict how he or she might score in the future. To the extent a student scores better than predicted, that’s considered “value-added” for which the teacher gets credit. If a student does worse than expected, it’s value-subtracted. 

While that’s better than simply comparing test scores across the board, education experts such as John Ewing, president of the nonprofit group Math for America, see serious flaws in the value-added model. 

An Economic Policy Institute report cites a study that found “across five large urban districts, among teachers who were ranked in the top 20 percent of effectiveness in the first year, fewer than a third were in that top group the next year, and another third moved all the way down to the bottom 40 percent.”  So a third of effective teachers became ineffective in one year?   

Meanwhile, the evaluations would create even more incentive for teachers to teach to the PSSA.  

An area high school teacher told me he knows teachers whose students do well on standardized tests but the kids hate their classes because they are mind-numbingly boring and generate no discussion or critical thinking.  Link job security to such assessments and  “teachers will teach to the test because it’s the safest thing they can do,” he said. 

“If you want your school system to be innovative and teach critical thought, the last thing you want to do is limit risk-taking,” he said. 

A final thought: My older son has had teachers who changed the direction of his life – giving him a passion and a goal for his future. Where on the new evaluation form will that kind of priceless gift be noted? 

I Am Knowledge February 03, 2012 at 04:51 PM
What? You don't do all this already?
Nancy Bonfanti February 03, 2012 at 05:03 PM
Not to belittle those courses but those are not core cirriculum. But, yes, they do test for gym theory...but not sure on the art and music. Good point though.
Nancy Bonfanti February 03, 2012 at 05:10 PM
Aren't there models that can be used...I'm wondering if the State has such a model. If they require the schools to get to a certain level to continue to fund it, then why can't they help them get to that level with the right teachers in place. And yes, "Grow Up Saucon" is right...the actual teacher's love of the job means a "disguinished" evaluation for that teacher. It would be obvious in the kids test scores and if students can be part of the evaluation it would show there as well. I love the idea of students having some say. After all, they have to sit there. Yes, some students have issues with a specific teacher but that one anomoly could be disregarded if there are no similar negative feedback. I think that type of feedback would have to be limited to middle and high school levels though. At K-4, I'm not sure a child can provide that feedback.
Nancy Bonfanti February 03, 2012 at 06:17 PM
I like it!!! There were some teachers I would have loved to recommend be fired and there were others I would have liked to have been given a dozen roses at the end of the school year.
mike schlicher February 06, 2012 at 06:08 AM
I am not a teacher nor do I have any children but what I see is that children need to learn a lot more communication skills both with other children as well as with adults respect is something earned and learnedand then children can pick up things from there .People go w/the premise that most kids dont get it well we are all wrong they do.Ask them a sports question or one about a car and so on if it interest them then they will listen and particapate.They can read the same things that we do with people telling them that they cant do things.I base these facts on a article I read where its called the McDONALDS mentality everything done reall fast and quick slow things down they will get it ,ONE CONCERNED ADULT LOOKING IN FROM THE OUTSIDE


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »