Utley to Third Base is Right Call

Moving Chase Utley to third base would fill a huge hole for Philadelphia Phillies next year.


The greatest second baseman in history might make a position change in 2013.

Chase Utley started fielding ground balls at third base before Wednesday night's game. And hopefully, he keeps doing it.

Because Utley's future with the Phillies is at third base.

The move makes perfect sense.

Utley, who has been on the disabled list the past two years because of degenerated knees, would be ideal at third where he wouldn't have to take such a pounding from going to his left and right all the time and from having base runners trying to take him out.

More important, the move may keep Utley in a Phils uniform for years to come if he's successful. Utley will be playing in the last year of his contract in 2013 so he's doing the right thing by trying to prolong his career.

Utley's a smart fellow. After all, he's the one who suggested this move to General Manager .

No Phillies fan wants to ever see Chase Utley depart the team. He's a fan favorite who can do no wrong. Philly fans love players who hustle.

And Utley is the closest player the Phils have to Charlie Hustle since...well...Charlie Hustle (Pete Rose) played for the team and won them a World Series in 1980.

Third base is a huge hole for the Phillies. And it has been for several years.

Placido Palanco just can't stay healthy to play the hot corner even though he is a Gold Glover. He also doesn't deliver the power numbers needed by your 3B guy.

Utley certainly does.

Kevin Frandsen, while showing some smark, is not your next third basemen. He's a great utility guy who could spell Utley next year at third.

So move Utley to third. This way it clears second base for Freddie Galvis, who was magical playing there to open the season before getting injured and suspended for violating baseball's drug policy.

Utley is doing the right thing for himself and the ballclub by going to third.

He tried to make the move a decade ago to replace Scott Rolen but was ineffective in Triple A. That was before he became Chase Utley, the star stud we all know and love.

You can't see a Phillies team without Utley in the lineup. And Galvis has earned his stripes.

These moves have also worked before.

Long ago, All-Star catcher Darren Daulton's knees were shot. So Dutch told the club he could still contribute. He took a spot in right field and did a decent job before being traded to the Florida Marlins, where he got a World Series ring.

We all want Chase Utley to get another World Series ring. His best chance is with the Philadelphia Phillies.

frank ciliberti September 01, 2012 at 04:22 PM
I think it would be a good move, if he can make the long throws.
Daryl Nerl September 01, 2012 at 05:34 PM
Looking beyond his injury issues, Utley has been in decline since 2008. Batting averages: .292, .282, .275, .259, .249; Home Runs: 33, 31, 16, 11, 9; RBI: 104, 93, 65, 44, 26. OPS is only bouncing back slightly from last year, but he is now a shadow of the player he was in 2007 when it was .976. He'll be 34 next year. He won't be getting better. So, from the perspective of this Mets fan, please, keep trotting him out there -- somewhere. The Flushing Faithful will be appreciative.
RenterNow September 02, 2012 at 03:49 AM
please - Frandsen deserves every shot at 3rd next year. What is hurting the phils is the production from Rollins/Utley/Howard. Utley will be gone to the American League after next year.
Daryl Nerl September 02, 2012 at 04:53 AM
I would agree. Frandsen has earned a shot to play every day. At this point, he is a better ballplayer than Polanco or Utley.
Dino Ciliberti September 02, 2012 at 02:11 PM
Yes, Utley's numbers have been in decline because he's also been injured. Give him a full healthy season and then judge his output. Frandsen can't hold a candle to Utley, he's no more than a utility player. Come on, Utley at 10 percent is better than most players.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »