Vitamins – Why the Controversy?

Vitamins are a $20 billion industry in the United States. Are they worth the money you are spending? Most of the time buying and eating fresh vegetables is the better alternative.

Vitamins –Over half of adults in the United States take a multivitamin, an annual $20 billion dollar industry in this country. We’ve heard a lot of stories about them recently, some contradictory.

Who would have thought a multivitamin would be bad for you? But the recently published Iowa Women’s Health Study indicates a higher risk of dying in women 50-65 years old who take vitamins, especially if they contain iron.

Vitamin E used to be touted as preventing heart disease and cancer. Several years ago the HOPE-TOO trial found that vitamin E not only didn’t protect against heart disease, but participants taking vitamin E were 13% more likely to experience heart failure. The SELECT trial showed 17% higher risk of prostate cancer in those who take Vitamin E.  Vitamin E has also been shown to increase the risk of hemorrhagic stroke (bleeding in the brain.) However, it does appear to slow macular degeneration in the eyes.

What does it all mean? And what are vitamins anyway? 

Vitamins are essential organic compounds that the human body needs for life, but cannot synthesize by itself. Therefore humans must consume these compounds in the diet. 

Important vitamins include the following:

  • Vitamin A: Carotenes, the yellow pigment found in vegetables like carrots, are pro-vitamins, which are converted into vitamin A, which is important in vision. 
  • Vitamin B: There are eight important B vitamins that help the body convert carbohydrates into glucose (sugar) for energy. B vitamins are involved in many of the body’s enzymatic reactions for metabolism, and are needed for good brain development. They also help red blood cell health and prevent anemia.
  • Vitamin C: It aids in absorption of iron, and is needed to form collagen in bones, cartilage muscle and blood vessels. It is found in citrus fruits such as oranges and limes. Limes were carried on board British Naval ships to prevent scurvy (vitamin C deficiency) in the sailor of the 18th and 19th centuries, thus the British sailor’s nickname of “limeys”.
  • Vitamin D: Otherwise known as the sunshine vitamin. As little as 10 minutes of sun exposure daily can prevent deficiency. D vitamins aid in absorption of calcium, helping to form and maintain strong bones and prevent osteoporosis. Vitamin D is found in milk and dairy products.
  • Vitamin E: Vitamin E is an antioxidant which protects cells from free radicals which may cause cell damage. It is also involved in immune function.

Unlike medications, vitamins as dietary supplements that you can buy in pill or liquid form do not have to be evaluated or approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). It is the responsibility of the manufacturer to ensure the product is safe and that label claims are accurate and truthful. Vitamins have been evaluated in deficiencies, but have not been well studied in healthy subjects until recently. Many of the studies are not well designed and are contradictory, without proof of the claims made (like no proof that vitamin C prevents colds.)

So what are we fairly certain about with vitamins?  Too much and too little can both be harmful. There is a healthful range. Vitamins A, D, E, and K are fat soluble vitamins and have known toxic levels. We used to think water soluble vitamins like B and C were not harmful in large amounts, and that the excess would just come out in the urine if not needed by the body. We now know that vitamin C in amounts greater than 2000mg/day increases the risk for kidney stones, causes excess iron absorption (with its own risks to the liver), and causes diarrhea. Excess vitamin B6 at 100mg/day can cause numbness in the fingers and toes.

Many foods in the United States, especially cereals, breads and flour are supplemented with extra vitamins. Also, there are mineral supplements added to food and drinks. These minerals are fraught with the same problems as the vitamins.

We know that vitamins naturally within foods are absorbed and used better in the body than those placed as supplements or those we take as pills. And there have been no cases of toxicity of vitamins from eating too much food, but people have certainly have overdosed on vitamins with tablets, powders, and vitamin drinks. People who eat the right foods and don’t have medical problems like difficulty with absorption, gastric bypass or genetic disorders are unlikely to have vitamin deficiencies.

 What’s the bottom line?  Grandma was right. Eat your vegetables!

Some useful references:
Fact sheets at NIH Office of Dietary Supplements.  http://ods.od.nih.gov/
National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine. http://nccam.nih.gov/
U.S. Pharmacopeia http://www.usp.org/USPVerified/dietarySupplements/
Eat Right American Dietetic Association http://www.eatright.org/Media/content.aspx?id=6442452592
Mayo Clinic http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/




This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Diane Berl September 11, 2012 at 12:15 PM
You are right to say "Eat your vegetables", but, because of the depletion of natural nutrients in our soils as well as the "fake" foods that are prevelant in our society, we need to take multi-vitamins. I agree that one should be careful with how much one takes and also be careful of what company makes them. Some of the commercial vitamins out there are just as harmful as the poisons in our food and water. Stick with vitamins made by a trusted company such as Shaklee, take only the recommended dose and check with your doctor so that it doesn't counter-act with any meds you take. Diane Berl http://brightfuture-helpingothers.blogspot.com
Madalyn Schaefgen, MD, FAAFP September 11, 2012 at 10:26 PM
Thanks for your comment, Diane. Sometimes taking a vitamin is appropriate, like folic acid for women in childbearing years, or vitamin D to prevent osteoporosis. Checking with your doctor before taking any vitamins is a great idea.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »